
Hybrid audio call, May 21, 2013
=======================================


Participants: Chulhee, Silvio, Mikolay, Nicolas, Glenn, Arthur, Marcus, Romuald, Savvas, Margaret



Agenda:

1. PVS generation: status

2. Common set: status

3. Other  




Call:
--------------------


1. PVS generation: status


     HD01 : (ready for upload)
     HD02 : (uploading, still not finished)
     HD03 : finalized
     HD04 : finalized 
     HD05 : src01, src10 were replaced, bitrates increased, start uploading
     HD06 : no update

     VGA01 : finalized
     VGA02 : ready for verification, one problem with one PVS, re-vised PVS is uploaded.
     VGA03 : problem with delays in packet arrival, see Silvio's email. re-discuss next week

     WVGA1 : uploading finished -- soon ready for checking.

     WVGA2 : (rebuffering) -- rebuffering sample produced by Marcus:
     
     --> delay discussion until next week, please write your opinion to the reflector.     
     


     --> Chulhee will write email with additional problem PVSs.

     


2. Common set: status:


   Number  | Lab     | Status
   samples |         |
   ----------------------------------------------
   6	Ghent HD     : ready for verification
   4	DT HD        : ready for verification
   4	AGH HDi      : ready for verification
   2	Yonsei HDi   : ready for verification --> will be replaced according to revised design
   4	IRCCyN HDi   : ready for verification
   2	Yonsei WVGA  : ready for verification - issues, see Chulhee's email
   3	Acreo WVGA   : ready for verification, 
   6	SwissqualVGA : ready for verification
   2	Yonsei VGA   : ready for verification
   7	OPTICOM VGA  : ready for verification


   
   Chulhee: Should the revised HRCs be used for the common set samples of Yonsei? 
   --> Yes, common set should be processed using revised HRCs. Then, a visual check
   will be performed to check that the whole quality range is covered by the common set.
   
   Savvas: checked HD3, HD4, are ok in his opinion.
   


3. Other:

   Schedule:    
   --> common set can be finalized faster than 2 weeks, if all proponents agree on the 
   samples.

   




For Information: evaluation data sets:

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|        | Format                        | Scene     | Design                | Test vectors    | PVS generations | Subjective Test |
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| HD01   | 60fps (interlaced)            | IRCCyN    | DT                    | RT-RK           | RT-RK           | IRCCyN          |
| HD02   | 50fps (interlaced)            | AGH       | AGH                   | RT-RK           | RT-RK           | AGH             |
| HD03   | 30fps (progressive)           | DT        | DT                    | DT              | DT              | DT              |
| HD04   | 25fps (progressive)           | Ghent     | Ghent                 | Ghent           | Ghent           | Ghent           |
| HD05   | 60fps (interlaced)            | Yonsei    | Yonsei                | Yonsei          | Yonsei          | Yonsei          |
| HD06   | 50fps (progressive), 1280*720 | FUB       | FUB                   | FUB             | FUB             | FUB             |
|        |                               |           |                       |                 |                 |                 |
| VGA01  | 30fps                         | Swissqual | Swissqual/Rebuffering | Swissqual       | Swissqual       | Yonsei          |
| VGA02  | 30fps                         | Yonsei    | Yonsei                | Yonsei          | Yonsei          | Swissqual       |
| VGA03  | 25fps                         | Opticom   | Opticom               | Opticom         | Opticom         | Yonsei          |
|        |                               |           |                       |                 |                 |                 |
| WVGA01 | 30fps                         | Yonsei    | Yonsei                | Yonsei          | Yonsei          | Opticom         |
| WVGA02 | 25fps                         | Acreo     | Acreo/Rebuffering     | FUB/RT-RK/Acreo | FUB/RT-RK/Acreo | Acreo           |




   

